News

Federal Court of Justice ruling on data reporting to SCHUFA – Non-material claim for damages in the event of impermissible reporting of disputed or non-enforceable claims

In its judgment of January 28, 2025 (Case No. VI ZR 183/22), the 6th Civil Senate of the Federal Court of Justice ruled that the defendant is entitled to non-pecuniary damages in the amount of 500 € under Art. 82 (1) GDPR as the plaintiff had reported the defendant’s personal data to SCHUFA without authorization. This report was inadmissible because the plaintiff’s claims were disputed and not legally enforceable. The unjustified entry affected the defendant’s creditworthiness and made it more difficult for her to participate in economic life.

In this case, a mobile phone provider had arranged for a negative SCHUFA entry at the expense of the defendant, although the corresponding claim was in dispute between the parties. The defendant alleged a violation of her data protection rights and, among other things, claimed non-pecuniary damages in the amount of 6,000 €.

In the appeal instance, the defendant only challenged the amount of non-pecuniary damages. The preceding question relevant to the decision regarding liability on the merits had already been positively established by the judgment of the court of second instance.

The Regional Court of Koblenz had initially dismissed the claim in the first instance as unfounded. Although it affirmed a data protection violation by the plaintiff, the Chamber dismissed the claim on the grounds that the defendant had not provided sufficient evidence of specific damages.

The 5th Senate of the Higher Regional Court of Koblenz then affirmed a claim for damages in the amount of 500 € in the appeal and emphasized that the amount is to be determined considering its function as compensation (1.) as well as for satisfaction and general prevention (2.). However, it also took into account the fact that the amount must not completely deter those responsible from reporting, since this is also in the interest of consumers. The Federal Court of Justice ultimately agreed with these considerations, but in its grounds for the decision it only referred to the compensatory function regarding the amount of the damages.

The following is a detailed account of the Federal Court of Justice’s considerations regarding the functions of the claim for damages for pain and suffering:

  1. Compensatory function due to the violation of the protected interest

Both the Higher Regional Court of Koblenz and the Federal Court of Justice comply with the broad interpretation required by recital 146 sentence 3 when assessing a claim for compensation and state that immaterial damage, even if it is minor in an individual case, must be compensated. The Federal Court considered the disclosure of the defendant’s personal data to the SCHUFA, which, in the context of possible SCHUFA queries, led to an entry at SCHUFA that could be viewed by an unknown number of third parties, to the detriment of the defendant. On the other hand, it took into account the fact that the entry at SCHUFA adversely affected the defendant’s creditworthiness and that, according to the unchallenged findings of the court of appeal, this had already had an adverse effect on the defendant, since her house bank had temporarily suspended the granting of credit.

  1. Satisfaction and general preventive function

The judges in Karlsruhe rejected the consideration of satisfaction and general preventive function as legally erroneous, with reference to the purely compensatory character of Art. 82 GDPR. However, they also stated that this did not work to the disadvantage of the defendant, since the damages were higher under the aspect of the dual function than they would have been if only the compensatory function had been considered. In doing so, the Federal Court relies primarily on the case law of the ECJ (see ECJ, judgment of June 20, 2024 – C-182/22 and C-189/22, NJW 2024, 2599 marginal no. 23 – Scalable Capital; Senate judgment of November 18, 2024 – VI ZR 10/24, DB 2024, 3091 para. 18; in each case with further references). Insofar as the Higher Regional Court of Koblenz attributes a function of satisfaction and general prevention to damages, it has misjudged the case law of the ECJ, which, among other things, points out that these functions are already fulfilled by the provisions in Articles 83 and 84 of the GDPR and that there is therefore no need for a further deterrent or even punitive function in the liability regime of the GDPR.

Conclusion: The Federal Court remains true to its previous restrictive decision-making practice and dogmatically pursues a clear line, so that the claimant of non-pecuniary damages resulting from a data protection violation must continue to present and prove such negative consequences going beyond pure data loss in the future as well. In determining the amount of damages, the Federal Court continues to follow the case law of the ECJ. Accordingly, neither the severity of the infringement nor the existence of a culpable act is relevant. Overall, this will probably further consolidate the scope for the fact-finding judge’s assessment when determining damages in the context of a breach of data protection violations. In practice, this means that the purely compensatory character of Art. 82 GDPR limits financial responsibility to the actual damage incurred.

Your contacts: